Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Beeswax's avatar

I'm 72 years old and have been a progressive since my late teens. I voted for "not Trump" (i.e., Joe Biden) in 2020. This time I wrote in the name of a Democratic state representative from Texas, Shawn Thierry. Thierry took a principled stance against the gender medicalization of children, for which she was evicted from the Democratic party. That's how the Dems roll. Charming, isn't it?

I applaud your efforts regarding the trans issue, but I have to say, it's not the whole story. Here's why:

The Democrats are the party of identity politics. While trans ideology is pernicious, dangerous and dumb, so is the rest of identity politics. I'm talking about DEI, ubiquitous in universities, corporations, even religious institutions and the U.S. Military. Cancellations, the destruction of peoples' careers, and an ever increasing animosity between the races is the result.

The Supreme Court thankfully shot down affirmative action, but mucking around with the country's origin story, and stirring up new levels of interracial hatred are tearing the country apart. Why was it deemed a winning strategy to make Kamala Harris our presidential nominee, when nobody had voted for her and she couldn't even answer a simple question: what will you do differently from Joe Biden once you become president? All anybody could say about Harris was that she's a "woman of color" and has a vagina that I assume she "identifies" with since we haven't heard her claim to be trans.

I'm only a little bit facetious. Identity politics, regardless of which identity we're talking about, is a bankrupt way of looking at human beings, and people in this country are sick of it. It's the special provenance of the Democrats.

Matt Walsh's recent documentary, "Am I Racist?" was a brilliant exposé of the racism and grifting that underlies DEI.

I now understand that DEI is a poison. People of all races find it offensive. Gender ideology is just one of its many permutations. They ALL need to go away. The Democrats should uncouple themselves from this divisive, tragic perspective on what are just normal variations among humans from different countries and backgrounds going back hundreds of millions of years.

There is one race, the Human Race. There are two sexes, Male and Female. To tie it all together, we have the Golden Rule.

Expand full comment
Melissa R.'s avatar

Thank you, DIAG.

I try to get people interesting in this topic--with very little success.

It has become my most important issue, as I have lost a daughter to trans ideology.

Everyone now seems to know a "trans kid" or young adult caught up in this identity. The affirming parents are often evangelists for trans identities. "Daughter is now my son. He is happy."

They can be a noisy bunch.

Meanwhile, many of us feel we can't voice our concerns, due to the relationship we hope to have with our trans-identified child.

Helen Joyce is correct. It is those affirming parents that will keep this trans machine rolling.

And what about young adults happy with their new selves?

They would be fine if they haven't medicalized. Why isn't that ever mentioned?

Expand full comment
61 more comments...

No posts